Puppies available now - Rowley, MA · (978) 504-1582
Just Behaving·Golden Retrievers
PuppiesCall or Text Dan(978) 504-1582Contact Us
Learn More
Our ProcessAboutOur Dogs
Explore
LearnJournalLibraryHealthFamily GuidesWikiResearchGallery
The Five Pillars|11 min read|Last reviewed 2026-04-05|HeuristicPending PSV

Raising vs. Training

Raising vs. Training is the philosophical distinction underneath almost everything JB says. The basic argument is that puppies are meant to develop into functional adults through social life, environmental structure, and guided maturation. Training, by contrast, is a formal process for producing specific behaviors through arranged contingencies. JB is not claiming that training can never produce results. JB is claiming that producing results is not the same thing as raising an organism. That argument is largely heuristic, even where it draws support from documented observations. Heuristic

What It Means

To raise a puppy is to build a developmental environment. To train a puppy is to engineer behavioral outcomes.

Those two projects can overlap in places, but they are not identical. Raising asks:

  • What kind of adult is this puppy becoming?
  • What social models surround the puppy?
  • What emotional floor does the household provide?
  • What behaviors are prevented from taking root in the first place?

Training asks a different set of questions:

  • What behavior do we want right now?
  • What cue will produce it?
  • What consequence will increase or decrease it?
  • How reliably can we reproduce it across repetitions?

JB's criticism is not that the second set of questions is always illegitimate. It is that the second set has become so culturally dominant that people now mistake it for the whole task of bringing up a young dog.

The historical layer matters here. The commensal pathway is the dominant scientific model for how dogs came into human life. Documented JB then adds its interpretive claim: if dogs entered human social worlds through long cohabitation and selection for proximity, then a modern raising framework that emphasizes social orientation, calm adult guidance, and environmental structure may be more continuous with that relationship than a highly formalized training paradigm. Heuristic

That is a carefully hedged claim. JB cannot say the Five Pillars were scientifically proven to be the selection pressures of domestication. They were not. SCR-001 is explicit about that boundary. What JB can say is that the developmental logic of social mammals and the historical dog-human relationship make the raising frame more coherent than the modern assumption that a puppy is primarily an obedience project.

Signal Precision helps sharpen the contrast. Natural social life works through timing, context, and relational legibility. Mixed Evidence Formalized training systems often replace that legibility with explicit cues, markers, and reinforcement schedules. Again, JB is not denying that those systems can be effective at behavior production. The point is that they represent a different architecture of adult-young relationship.

This is why JB often says the method creates the need for the method. That phrase must be handled with great care. It is one of the highest slippage risks in the whole knowledge base. SCR-158 does not license the claim as settled historical science. It licenses it as a heuristic thesis about what happens when living with dogs is reorganized into formalized instruction. The more life is chopped into cue-reward-management cycles, the more the adult may need those cycles to keep the dog organized.

The practical distinction becomes:

  • raising develops internal organization
  • training manages displayed behavior

JB's argument is that most families actually want the first outcome, even when the industry keeps selling them the second process.

Why It Matters for Your Dog

This distinction changes what success looks like.

If the goal is training, success is usually measured by performance: the puppy sits, stays, comes, waits, lies down, or stops doing something when told.

If the goal is raising, success looks broader:

  • the puppy settles more easily
  • the puppy reads household rhythm
  • the puppy handles frustration with more maturity
  • the puppy needs less active management over time
Philosophical Position

JB is not trying to replace one training method with another. It is trying to move the center of gravity from behavior management to developmental raising.

This also explains why JB does not accept the industry's favorite false binary: reward versus punishment. That framing assumes the main question is which behavior-control technology the adult will use. JB says there is a prior question. Why are we treating the whole relationship as a behavior-control problem to begin with?

That does not eliminate the value of skill teaching. Families still need practical behaviors. But inside JB, specific skills are meant to sit downstream of the developmental environment, not replace it.

The Evidence

DocumentedEmpirical background JB builds on
HeuristicJB's central thesis

SCR References

Scientific Claims Register
SCR-001Proto-dogs self-domesticated by approaching human camps; calmer individuals selected for proximity tolerance.Documented
SCR-003Adult dogs deploy social signals with contextual precision rather than indiscriminate output.Mixed Evidence
SCR-158Formalization of dog training emerged from institutional need, not from relational learning failure.Heuristic

Sources

  • Hare, B. & Woods, V. (2013). The Genius of Dogs. Dutton.
  • Coppinger, R. & Coppinger, L. (2001). Dogs: A New Understanding of Canine Origin, Behavior, and Evolution. University of Chicago Press.
  • Horowitz, A. (2009). Inside of a Dog: What Dogs See, Smell, and Know. Scribner.
  • Bekoff, M. (2007). The Emotional Lives of Animals. New World Library. ���������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������������